A huge Adobe Structure, A Novelty from the Iron Age III in Qara-Hasanlu, Namin, Ardabil

Authors

1 PhD student in Archaeology, Department of Archaeology, Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Mohaghegh Ardabili, Ardabil, Iran.

2 Professor, Department of Archaeology, Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Mohaghegh Ardabili, Ardabil, Iran (Corresponding Author).

3 PhD in Archaeology, General Directorate of Education, Bukan County, Bukan, Iran.

4 M.A. student in Archaeology, Department of Archaeology, Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Mohaghegh Ardabili, Ardabil, Iran.

10.22084/nb.2023.26886.2527

Abstract

Abstract
During the systematic archaeological excavations at the historical site of Qara-Haslanlu in Namin, numerous significant cultural artifacts were uncovered, which are crucial for the comprehensive analysis and exploration of this location. Among the various discoveries, including pottery shers, bones, burial sites, and metal and gold items, a substantial adobe structure was revealed at the hill’s center, notable for its unique architectural design, marking it as the sole architectural phase in the region; its significance has consequently been heightened. This remarkable architectural feature is constructed entirely from stone and clay, encircled by a series of supporting structures. This study has introduced the adobe structure recovered using a descriptive-analytical approach, drawing on both fieldwork and library resources. The main questions addressed include: What are the architectural characteristics of this large adobe structure, to which historical period does it belong, and what was its intended function? Findings indicate that the adobe structure or platform, covering roughly 833 square meters, is entirely constructed of adobe, except for three lower stone ridges which found only on the exterior sides. The structure aligns with and continues the platform-building tradition of Iron Age II and III, and it was likely used for ritual purposes. Additionally, the analysis of pottery from the Qara-Hasanlu area, compared with findings from other sites, supports the conclusion that this substantial adobe platform dates back to the late Iron Age or the Parthian period.
Keywords: Qara-Hasanlu Site, Namin, Clay Structure, Pottery, Iron Age, Parthian Period.
 
Introduction
The large adobe structure at Qara-Hasanlu stands out as the only known platform of its kind in northwestern Iran, distinguished by its unique architectural style and located in the center of the Ardabil Plain. The outer portion of this substantial structure features three rows of stone and seven rows of bricks, while its interior is entirely filled with layered clay. Generally, most archaeological research related to excavations and ancient sites has concentrated on artifacts like pottery and other small finds, with relatively little focus on architectural elements and structures. In this context, examining the architectural aspects of the adobe structure at Qara-Hasanlu is highly valuable for understanding the features, characteristics, and traditions of Iron Age platform architecture in northwestern Iran, serving as a foundation for more in-depth study. Such research should be approached with scientific rigor.
Research Questions: 1. What are the architectural features of the large adobe structure in the Qara-Hasanlu area? 2. To which historical period does the large adobe structure of the Qara-Hasanlu area belong? 3. What was the function and purpose of the large adobe structure at Qara-Hasanlu?
Research Method: This article employs a descriptive-analytical research method, drawing on findings from excavations and field surveys conducted in the specified area. Alongside numerous small cultural artifacts uncovered in the excavation trenches, a significant architectural feature the large adobe structure was also identified, thoroughly examined, and scientifically analyzed during systematic archaeological investigations in the Qara-Hasanlu area. This discovery has further elevated the site’s archaeological significance. To support and deepen the analysis, library research and comparisons with contemporary structures have also been utilized.
Qara-Hasanlu Mound: Qara-Hasanlu is situated within the boundaries of Namin Town in Ardabil Province. It lies along the Ardabil–Ab-Biglo Road, approximately one kilometer from the main road, positioned in the heart of the Ardabil Plain. The site is located 2 kilometers northwest of Qara-Hasanlu village and 9 kilometers east of the city of Ardabil, in a broad, open plain.
Qara-Hasanlu Adobe Structure or Platform: One of the most significant architectural discoveries at Qara-Hasanlu is a clay platform, remains of which have been uncovered in several trenches across the mound and within the natural sediments. This large structure, featuring a three-row stone foundation made of rubble and large stone fragments, has a body constructed entirely of clay and is situated at the center of the mound.
 
Analysis of the findings
A) Chronology of the clay platform
The adobe platform was constructed on a mound dating back to Iron Age I and II, indicating that it does not belong to the same period. Therefore, it can be concluded that the mound was reused for building the adobe platform during the late Iron Age III or the Parthian Period, after it had been previously abandoned.
b) Use of clay platform:
Regarding the function of the large clay platform, it is likely that this architectural structure served a ritual purpose.
 
Conclusion
The archaeological investigations conducted at the Qara-Hasanlu site have yielded substantial evidence reflecting cultural traditions from Iron Age I and II, as well as the Parthian Period, within the Ardabil Plain. Among the most significant datable cultural materials retrieved from the site are pottery fragments, which predominantly correspond to the Iron Age (I and II) and the historical Parthian Period. However, the most prominent and aesthetically remarkable feature discovered at the site is the large adobe structure. This monumental platform features a building composed of three lower rows of stone and seven outer rows of adobe bricks, reinforced with structural supports. Its core and upper sections, extending down to the virgin soil, consist of twelve successive layers of compacted clay. The adobe platform at Qara-Hasanlu may be interpreted as a continuation of the Iron Age III architectural tradition of platform construction, comparable to similar structures found at sites such as Tepe Sialk in Kashan, Konar Sandal and Jiroft, Nushijan in Malayer, Pasargadae and Persepolis, Deh-No in Khuzestan, and Qaleh Darvish in Qom. Furthermore, evidence of platform surface cuts and the placement of burials atop the clay layers, alongside the presence of Iron Age I and II ceramics within the cultural strata of the site, suggests that the adobe platform may have initially been constructed during the Iron Age and later reutilized in the Parthian Period. Nevertheless, the occurrence of Iron Age pottery embedded within the brick matrix indicates that the area was originally settled during the Iron Age, with the current clay platform being constructed in a subsequent era. In conclusion, considering that the majority approximately 90% of the ceramic assemblage from Qara-Hasanlu is attributable to the Parthian Period, it is highly plausible to assign a relative chronological placement of the adobe platform to the Parthian era.

Keywords

Main Subjects


- آذرنوش، مسعود، (1354). «کاوش‌های گورستان محوطۀ سنگ‌شیر». گزارش‌های سومین مجمع سالانه کاوش‌ها و پژوهش‌های باستان‌شناسی ایران، به‌کوشش: فیروز باقرزاده، تهران: مرکز باستان‌شناسی ایران: 72-51.
- آقالاری، بایرام؛ و ده‌پهلوان، مصطفی، (1390). «شاخصه‌های فرهنگی شمال‌غرب ایران در دورۀ اشکانی، با نگاهی به یافته‌های فصل دوم کاوش تپه کهنه پاسگاه تپه‌سی». مطالعات باستان‌شناسی، 3 (1): 15-43. https://jarcs.ut.ac.ir/article_28693.html
- ایروانی‌قدیم، فرشید، (1389). «گزارش حفاری فصل اوّل کاوش باستان‌شناسی کورگان‌های جعفرآباد». سازمان میراث‌فرهنگی کشور، تهران (منتشرنشده).
- ایروانی‌قدیم، فرشید؛ و ممی‌زاده‌گیگلو، سلیمان، (1391). «گونه‌شناسی و معرفی سفال‌های عصر آهن کورگان‌های جعفرآباد خدا آفرین». مطالعات باستان‌شناسی، 2 (4): 33-50. https://doi.org/10.22059/jarcs.2013.32118
- احمدى‌واستانى، سهیل، (1399). «کندوکاوی بر الگو‌های تدفین ایران در دوره اشکانی و ساسانی با استناد به کاوش‌های باستان‌شناسی». باستان‌شناسی ایران، 10(2): 16-39.
- استروناخ، دیوید، (1390). نوشیجان 1: بناهای بزرگ دوره ماد. ترجمۀ کاظم ملازاده، همدان: انتشارات دانشگاه بوعلی‌سینا.
- باقریان، محمدرضا، (1384). «گمانه‌زنی به‌منظور تعیین حریم محوطۀ باستانی چره». اداره میراث‌فرهنگی استان گیلان، (چاپ نشده).  
- پورفرج، اکبر، (1396). «تبیین و گاهنگاری فرهنگ‌های هزارۀ اول پ.م. در شهرستان نیر اردبیل». مطالعات باستان‌شناسی، 9 (1): 37 - 54. https://doi.org/10.22059/jarcs.2017.64004
- جعفری‌دهقی، محمود، (1393). «نگاهی تازه به کتیبه پهلوی آذرشب مشهور به نیروگاه سیکل ترکیبی (کازرون چهارده)». مجلۀ زبان‌شناخت، 5 (2): 21-29.
- جعفری‌زاده، مسلم؛ و سراقی، نعمت‌الله، (1394). «الگوهای استقراری دورۀ اشکانی دشت نهاوند». پژوهش‌های باستان‌شناسی مدرس، 12 و 13: 25-39.
- حدادیان، محمدرضا؛ فیروزمندی، بهمن؛ و صمغ‌آبادی، رضا، (1397). «بررسی سفال عصر آهن شمال فلات‌مرکزی ایران مطالعه موردی منطقه طالقان». باستان‌شناسی ایران، 8 (2): 116 - 131
- خان‌محمدی، بهروز، (1389). «مقبره‌ای از عصر آهن در بایزیدآباد نقده». آذربایجان غربی، باستان‌پژوهی، 8: 67-76.
- خلعتبری، محمدرضا، (1387). «گزارش مقدماتی لایه‌نگاری و اولین فصل کاوش محوطه استقراری کلورز (رستم‌آباد 1385 - 1387)». اداره کل میراث‌فرهنگی، صنایع‌دستی و گردشگری گیلان، (منتشرنشده).
- رضالو، رضا، (1385). «گزارش اولین فصل کاوش‌های باستان‌شناسی در گورستان خانقاه گیلوان». اردبیل: اداره کل میراث‌فرهنگی، صنایع‌دستی و گردشگری، (منتشرنشده).
- رضالو، رضا؛ و آیرملو، یحیی، (1393). «فرهنگ دوران مفرغ جدید و آهن I دشت اردبیل مطالعۀ موردی قلعه خسرو قلعه‌های اقماری». پژوهش‌های باستان‌شناسی ایران، 4(6): 65-84. https://nbsh.basu.ac.ir/article_842.html
- سعیدیان، سعدی؛ و قلی‌زاده، فاطمه، (1398). «مجموعه بنای عصر آهن تیله هویوک؛ نشانه‌ای از حضور مادها در آسیای صغیر». اولین کنفرانس ملی باستان‌شناسی و تاریخ هنر ایران، دانشگاه بابلسر: 215-230.
- ستارنژاد، سعید؛ اسماعیلی، حسین؛ رحمت‌پور، محمد؛ ژاله‌اقدم، جواد؛ و توحیدی، محسن، (1399). «گزارش مقدماتی فصل نخست کاوش باستان‌شناختی گورستان سرند- دغدغان آذربایجان شرقی». پژوهش‌های باستان‌شناسی ایران، 11 (30): 73 - 100. https://doi.org/10.22084/nb.2020.22518.2203
- سرلک، سیامک؛ و ملک‌زاده، مهرداد، (1384). «آجرهای منقوش عصر آهن پایانی ماد شرقی، سکوی خشتی قلی درویش جمکران و سازه بزرگ سیلک کاشان». باستان‌شناسی، 1 (1): 52 - 66.
- سلیمی، صلاح؛ ده‌پهلوان، مصطفی؛ و داودی، حسین، (1397). «بررسی گورستان های خمره ای حاشیه شرقی رودخانه زاب کوچک در شهرستان سردشت، شمال‌غرب ایران». مطالعات باستان‌شناسی، 10 (17: 1): 135-153. https://doi.org/10.22059/jarcs.2018.226461.142390
- طاهری‌دهکردی، معصومه، (1391). «تاریخچه پژوهش‌های دورۀ ماد». مجموعه مقالات 80 سال باستان‌شناسی ایران (جلد دوم)، به‌کوشش: یوسف حسن‌زاده و سیما میری، تهران: نشر پازینه.
- طهماسبی، فریبرز، (1388). «مطالعه و بررسی گورهای تاریخی گورستان خانقاه گیلوان خلخال». پایان‌نامۀ کارشناسی ارشد، دانشگاه آزاد واحد ابهر، دانشکده علوم انسانی.
- علیزاده‌سولا، محمد؛ رضالو، رضا؛ حاجی‌زاده، کریم؛ و افخمی، بهروز، (1397). «بررسی‌های باستان‌شناختی شرق آذربایجان؛ فصل اول: شمال شهرستان نمین، استان اردبیل». مطالعات باستان‌شناسی، 10 (18: 2): 221 - 238. https://doi.org/10.22059/jarcs.2019.68542
- کاظم‌لویه، علی؛ مافی، فرزاد؛ و فخار، زرین، (1400). «بررسی و مطالعه باستان‌شناختی زیست‌گاه‌های دورۀ اشکانی حوضه سفیدرود رودبار». مطالعات باستان‌شناسی، 13 (27: 3): 252- 263. https://doi.org/10.22059/jarcs.2020.280981.142716
- کامبخش‌فرد، سیف‌الله، (1377). گورخمره‌های اشکانی. تهران: مرکز نشر دانشگاهی.
- کامبخش‌فرد، سیف‌الله، (1344). «آثار و بقایای دهکده‌های پارتی اشکانی در مغان و آذربایجان». بررسی‌های تاریخی، 2 (1): 5-20.
- کرتیس، جان، (1393). نوشیجان 3، یافته‌های کوچک. ترجمۀ کاظم ملازاده، همدان: دانشگاه بوعلی سینا.
- لجمیری، مژده؛ و زارع‌خلیلی، مرضیه، (1383). «معرفی یک محوطۀ باستانی در اردبیل، قوشاتپه»، باستان‌پژوهشی، 12: 82- 88.
- محمدی‌فر، یعقوب؛ و فلاح‌مهنه، مهدی، (1394). «دورۀ اشکانی در شمال‌شرق ایران، محوطه‌های نویافته دشت درگز». دومین همایش باستان‌شناسی ایران، دانشگاه بیرجند: 1-16.
- ملازاده، کاظم، (1393). باستان‌شناسی ماد. تهران: انتشارات سمت.
- ملازاده، کاظم؛ محمدیان‌منصور، صاحب؛ جوانمردی، فاطمه؛ و خدابنده، مریم، (1395). «بررسی تناسبات و نظام پیون در معماری دوره ماد، مطالعه موردی نوشیجان». نشریه جستارهای باستان‌شناسی ایران پیش از اسلام، 1 (2): 79-93. https://iaej.sku.ac.ir/article_10166.html
- ملک‌زاده، مهرداد، (1383). «پشته خشتی سیلک، سازه‌ای از دورۀ ماد یا زیگوراتی». مجله باستان‌شناسی و تاریخ، 2 (36): 60 - 82.
- ملک‌زاده، مهرداد، (1385). «آجرهای منقوش عصر آهن پایانی ماد شرقی». فصلنامه تاریخ ایران باستان، 3: 18 - 45.
- مهرآفرین، رضا؛ روستایی، محمدصادق؛ و علایی‌مقدم، جواد، (1392). «سفال داغدار، سفال شاخص دورۀ اشکانی در سیستان ایران». پژوهش‌های باستان‌شناسی ایران، 4 (6): 105 - 120. https://nbsh.basu.ac.ir/article_844.html
- مهرآفرین، رضا؛ علیزاده، فاطمه؛ و شیرازی، روح‌اله، (1391). «سفال مکران در دورۀ اشکانی و هم‌گونی‌های آن با مناطق هم‌جوار». نامه باستان‌شناسی، 2 (3): 7 -24. https://nbsh.basu.ac.ir/article_442.html
- نقشینه، امیرصادق، (1389). «گونه شناسی سفال عصر آهن پیلاقلعه، رودبار گیلان»، مجله پیام باستان‌شناس، 7 (13): 73-90.
- نوبری، علیرضا؛ و صالحی‌گروسی، مهناز، (1384). «هنر سفالگری در گورستان مسجد کبود تبریز». مجله باستان‌پژوهی، 1 (1): 30-38.
- نورزاده، منوچهر، (1395). «بررسی و تحلیل باستان‌شناختی قلعه‌های تاریخی شهرستان نمین».  پایان‌نامۀ کارشناسی ارشد، دانشگاه محقق اردبیلی، دانشکده علوم انسانی، اردبیل (منتشر نشده).
- نورزاده، منوچهر، (1396). «مطالعه قلاع تاریخی شهرستان نمین و نقش آن در روابط دوسویه فرهنگی- تاریخی با منطقه قفقاز». سومین همایش ملی باستان‌شناسی ایران، تهران.
- هرینگ، ارنی، (1376). سفال ایران در دورۀ اشکانی. ترجمۀ حمیده چوبک، تهران: سازمان میراث‌فرهنگی کشور.
 
- Aghalari, B. & DehPahlavan, M., (1390). “Cultural indicators of northwestern Iran in the Parthian period, with a look at the findings of the second chapter of the excavation of the old hill of Pasgah Tepesi”.Archaeological Studies, 3(1): 15-43.  https://jarcs.ut.ac.ir/article_28693.html (in Persian)
- Ahmadi Vastani, S., (2020). “An exploration of Iranian burial patterns in the Parthian and Sassanid periods with reference to archaeological excavations”. Archeology of Iran, 10(2): 16-39
- Alizadeh Sola, M., Reza, R., Hajizadeh, K. & Afkhami, B., (2017). “Archaeological investigations of East Azerbaijan; First chapter: North of Nemin city, Ardabil province”. Archaeological Studies, 10(2): 221-238, https://doi.org/10.22059/jarcs.2019.68542 (in Persian)
- Azarnoush, M., (1975). “Excavations of the Seng-Shir cemetery”. Reports of the third annual conference of archaeological excavations and researches in Iran, by Firouz Bagherzadeh, Tehran: Iran Archeology Center: 51-72 (in Persian)
- Bagherian, M., (2014). “Speculation to determine the boundaries of the Chereh ancient site”. Cultural Heritage Department of Gilan Province, unpublished, (in Persian)
- Blaylock, S., (2009). Tille Höyük 3.1: The Iron Age: Introduction, Stratification and Architecture. The British Institute at Ankara, Monograph 41, London
- Burney, C., (1972). “Excavations at Haftavān Tepe 1969: Second Preliminary Report”. Iran, 10(1): 127-142. https://doi.org/10.2307/4300469
- Burton-Brown, T., (1951). Excavations in Azerbaijan 1948. London: John Murray.
- Curtis, J., (2013). Noushijan 3, Small findings. translated by Kazem Molazadeh, Hamedan: Boali Sina University, (in Persian)
- Egami, N., Fukai, S. &  Masuda, S., (1966). Dailaman II, the excavations at Noruzmahale and Khoramrud 1960. the Institute of Oriental Culture, The Tokyo University Iraq-Iran archaeological expedition, report. Paris (in Persian)
- Hadadian, M., Firouzmandi, B. & Samaghabadi, R., (2017). “Investigation of Iron Age Pottery in the North Central Plateau of Iran, a Case Study of Taleghan Region”. Archeology of Iran, 8(2): 116-131, (in Persian).
- Haerinck, E., (1988). The Iron Age in Guilan- Proposal for a chronology, In: Bronzeworking Centres of Western Asia c.1000-539 B.C.. JohnCurtis (ed.), London.
- Hemmati Azandariani, E., Malekzadeh, M. & Naseri Soumea, H., (2018). “Preliminary report of the first chapter of salvage excavation in the site of Haji Khan Famnin - Hamadan province, a new temple and shrine from the Medes period”. Archaeological Researches, 9 (23): 91- 110. (in Persian).
- Herring, E., (1997). Iran's pottery during the Parthian era. translated by Hamida Chobak, Tehran: Iran's Cultural Heritage Organization
- Iravani, F. & Mamizadeh Giglo, S., (2013). “Typology and Introduction of Iron Age Pottery from the Jafarabad Kurgans of Khodaafrin”. Archaeological Studies, 4(2): 33-50, https://doi.org/10.22059/jarcs.2013.32118 (in Persian)
- Iravani, F., (2009). “Excavation report of the first chapter of the archaeological excavation of Jafarabad Kurgans”. Cultural Heritage Organization of the country, unpublished, Tehran, (in Persian)
- Jafari Dehghi, M., (2013). “A Fresh Look on the Pahlawi Inscription of Azarshab Known as Niroogahe Sicle Tarkibi (Kazeroon fourteen)”. Journal of zabanshenakht, 5(2): 21-29, (in Persian).
- Jafarizadeh, M. & Saraghi, N., (2014). “Settlement Patterns of the Parthian Period of the Nahavand Plain”. Modares Archaeological Researches, 12 & 13: 25-39, (in Persian).
- Kambakhshfard, S., (1965). “Artifacts and Remains of Parthian Villages in Mughan and Azerbaijan”. Historical Surveys, 1(2): 20-5, (in Persian).
- Kambakhshfard, S., (1998). Parthian tombs. Tehran: University Publishing Center, (in Persian) 
- Kazemi Luyeh, A., Mafi, F. & Fakhar, Z., (1400). “Archaeological investigation and study of Parthian period habitats in Sefidroud Rudbar area”. Archaeological Studies, 13(3): 252-263,  https://doi.org/10.22059/jarcs.2020.280981.142716 (in Persian)
- Keall, E. J. & Keall, M. J., (1981). “The Qal'eh-i Yazdigird Pottery: A Statistical Approach”. IRAN, 19: 33-80. https://doi.org/10.2307/4299706
- Khalatbari, M. R., (2009). “Preliminary report of stratification and the first season of exploration of the settlement site of Culverz (Rostamabad 1385-1387)”. General Directorate of Cultural Heritage, Handicrafts and Tourism of Gilan, (Unpublished), (in Persian).
- Khanmohammadi, B., (2010). “A tomb from the Iron Age in Bayzidabad Naqdeh”. West Azerbaijan, Bastan-Pazhuhi, 8: 67-76, (in Persian).
- Kleiss, W., (1969). “Bericht uber zwei Erkundungsfahrten in Nordwest-Iran”. Archaologische Mitteilungen aus Iran, 2: 7-119.
- Kleiss. W., (1970). “Zur Topographie des Partherhanges in Bisutun”. AMI, 3: 133-168.
- Lajmiri, M. & Zare Khalili, M., (2013). “Introduction of an ancient site in Ardabil, Ghoshatpe”. Bastan-Research, 12: 82-88, (in Persian).
- Malekzadeh, M., (1383). “Silk clay pile, a structure from the Median period or ziggurat”. Journal of Archeology and History, 36: 60-82, (in Persian)
- Malekzadeh, M., (1385). “The carved bricks of the Late Iron Age of the Eastern Medes”. Quarterly Journal of Ancient Iranian History, 3: 45-18, (in Persian)
- Mehrafarin, R., Alizadeh, F. & Shirazi, R., (1391). “Makran pottery in the Parthian period and its similarities with the neighboring regions”.Archeological Journal, 2(3): 24-7, https://nbsh.basu.ac.ir/article_442.html (in Persian)
- Mehrafarin, R., Rustaie, M. S. & Alaei Moghadam, J., (2013). “Daghdar Pottery, an Indicative Pottery of the Parthian Period in Sistan, Iran”. Archaeological Researches of Iran, 4(6): 105-120. https://nbsh.basu.ac.ir/article_844.html (in Persian)
- Mehrafarin, R., Musavi Haji, S. R. & Alifeyz, S., (2011). “A Study of the seramics of East Iran During the Later Parthian Era with Special Reference to Tapa Gowri”. Central Asiatic Journal International Peri odical for the Languages, Literature, History and Archaeology of Central Asia: 240 – 258. (in Persian)
- Mohammadifar, Y. & Falah Mahneh, M., (2014). “Parthian Period in Northeast Iran, New Areas of Darghz Plain”. 2nd Iranian Archeology Conference, Birjand University: 16-16, (in Persian)
- Mollazadeh, K., (2013). Archaeology of Mad. Tehran: Samt Publications, (in Persian)
- Mollazdeh, K., Mohammadian M. S., Javanmardi, F. & Khodabandeh, M., (2015). “Investigation of proportions and Pion system in Median architecture, a case study of Noushijan”. Journal of Archeology of Pre-Islamic Iran, 1(2): 79-93, https://iaej.sku.ac.ir/article_10166.html (in Persian)
- Muscarella, O. W., (1974). “The Iron Age at Dinkha Tepe, Iran”. Metropolitan Museum Journal, 9: 35-90. https://doi.org/10.2307/1512656
- Nakhsineh, A., (2019). “Typology of Iron Age Pottery of Pilaqleah, Rudbar, Gilan”. Payam Archeology Journal, 7 (19): 73-90 (in Persian)
- Negahban, E. O., (1996). Marlik: the complete excavation report (Vol. 87). University of Pennsylvania, Museum of Archaeology, (in Persian)
- Nobari, A. & Salehi Grossi, M., (2014). “Pottery art in Tabriz Blue Mosque cemetery”. Bastan-Research Magazine, 1(1): 30-38, (in Persian)
- Nourzadeh, M., (2017). “Study of the historical castles of Nemin city and its role in bilateral cultural-historical relations with the Caucasus region”. 3rd National Conference on Archaeology of Iran, (in Persian)
- Nourzadeh, M., (2016). “Investigate and analyze the historic castles or forts city of Namin”. Thesis is approved for the degree of M.A. Department of Archaeology, University of Mohaghegh Ardabili, Faculty of Literature & Human Sciences, Ardabil, (in Persian)
- Olivier, L., (2012). “Clay sealings from the Iron Age citadel at Ulug Depe”. Archäologische Mitteilungen aus Iran und Turan, Vol. 44. Dietrich Reimer Verlag GmbH for Deutsches Archäologisches Institut & Eurasien-Abteilung Außenstelle Teheran: 313–328.
- Porfaraj, A., (2016). “Explanation and chronology of cultures of the first millennium BC in Nir Ardabil city”. Archaeological Studies, 9(1): 37-54,  https://doi.org/10.22059/jarcs.2017.64004 (in Persian)
- Rezaloo, R. & Ayramloo, Y., (2014). “The Late Bronze Age and Iron Age I Cultures in Ardabil Plain: Qalla Khosrow and Peripheral Castles”. Pazhoheshha-ye Bastan shenasi Iran, 4(6): 65-84. https://nbsh.basu.ac.ir/article_842.html (in Persian)
- Rezaloo, R., (2006). “Report of the first season of archaeological excavations in Gilvan Monastery cemetery”. Ardabil: Organization of Cultural Heritage, Handicrafts and Tourism, (in Persian)
- Roaf, M., (2008). “Medes beyond the borders of modern Iran”. Bastanpazhuhi (persian journal of Iranian Studies), 3(6): 9-11.
- Saeidian, S. & Qolizadeh, F., (2018). “Tile Hoyuk Iron Age Building Collection; A sign of the presence of the Medes in Asia Minor”. The first national conference on archeology and art history of Iran, Babolsar University, Ardibehesht: 215-230, (in Persian)
- Salimi, S., Dehpahlavan, M. & Davoudi, H., (2018). “A Study on the Parthian Pithos Cemeteries in the Western Bank of the Little Zab River in Sardasht, North-West Iran”. Journal of Archaeological Studies, 10(1): 135-153. https://doi.org/10.22059/jarcs.2018.226461.142390 (in Persian)
- Sarlak, S. & Malekzadeh, M., (1384). “The carved bricks of the Late Iron Age of Eastern Media, the Qoli-Darvish adobe platform of Jamkaran and the large Silk structure of Kashan”. Archeology Quarterly, 1(1): 52-66 (in Persian)
- Sattarnejad, S., Esmaili, H., Rahmatpour, M., Jale Aghdam, J. & Toheidi, M., (2019). “Preliminary report of the first chapter of archaeological exploration of Sarand cemetery - Daghdaghan, East Azerbaijan”. Archaeological Research, 3 (11): 73-100, https://doi.org/10.22084/nb.2020.22518.2203 (in Persian)
- Schaeffer, C., (1948). Stratigraphie Comparée et Chronologie de l’Asie Occidentale. london: Oxford university Press.
- Schmidt, E. F., (1957). “The cemetery of Persepolis Spring”. Persepolis II, The University of Chicago Press, LXIX: 117-157.
- Solecki, R. S., (1999). “An archaeological survey in Western Azarbaijan, Iran, the Iranian world”. in: A. Alizadeh, Y. Majidzadeh and S. MalekShahmirzadi (eds.), Assay on Iranian art and archaeology, presented to Ezat O. Negahban, Tehran, University Press: 28-43.
- Sono, T. & Fukai,S., (1968). Dailaman III, the excavations at Hasani Mahale and Ghalekuti 1964. The University Iraq-Iran archaeological expedition (in Persian).
- Stronach, D., (2011). Noushijan 1: The Great Buildings of the Median Period. translated by Kazem Molazadeh, Boali Sina University Publications, (in Persian)
- Tadahiko, O., Nokandeh, J. & Kazuya, Y., (2004). Preliminary Report of the Iran Japan Joint Archaeological Expedition to Gilan. Second Season 2002. 
- Taheri Dehkordi, M., (2013). History of Median Period Researches, Collection of Articles of 80 Years of Iranian Archeology (Volume II), by Yusuf Hassanzadeh and Sima Miri, Tehran: Pazineh Publishing, (in Persian)
- Tahmasabi, F., (2018). “Study and investigation of historical graves of Gilvan Khalkhal monastery cemetery”. master's thesis, Abhar Branch Azad University, Faculty of Humanities.